Feast of the Dedication of the Basilica of St. John Lateran
[In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.] Sometimes we hear things that sound good or make apparent sense, which, in the end, do not hold up. I’m the sort of guy who generally fills up my gas tank when it’s half full, and I started doing this because, when I was young, someone (I can’t remember for sure who) told me that gas could freeze in the tank in the winter if there was room in the tank. I recently mentioned that, and the other person challenged me on the factuality of that claim. And it turns out, gas freezes somewhere between -40º and -200º Fahrenheit. So it’s not going to freeze. And even if the temperature at which gas freezes is higher, it would freeze whether they tank was half full or entirely full. So, myth busted.
We might have heard another myth: that I can worship God just as well outside a church as I can inside a church. People may say that they feel closer to God in nature. Or they feel the comfort of God’s presence best in their home. Or, in a post-COVID world, some will say that they prefer to attend Mass via livestream. Certainly, God is present everywhere, indoors and outdoors. Certainly our homes are places of comfort. And, for a while, many people’s legitimate only access point to the Mass was through a computer screen.
The tricky thing about bad teachings is that something which is false tends to include something that is true. If it had no truthful aspect, we would reject it outright. But if it has some truth to it, we might choose to believe because we recognize some aspect of truth. So yes, God is present everywhere. Yes, people can easily experience God in nature. Yes, God does sometimes give us comfort, and our homes can remind us of that comforting presence of God. And yes, what churches broadcast through the livestream is the Mass, and for the sick or those who cannot drive to Mass, that is a better way to celebrate Sunday, the Lord’s Day, rather than just watching the NFL or playing Yahtzee.
But just because God is everywhere doesn’t mean He is equally present everywhere. God can be experienced through a beautiful sunset, or a powerful storm. But the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of the Son of God, Jesus Christ, brings God’s presence to us in a way that occurs no where else outside of a church. I promise you that the Eucharist will not materialize before you in your hunting blind on Saturday. Saints like St. Clare have had visions of the Eucharist (which is why she is the patron saint of television), but the unique presence of Christ in the Eucharist comes with a church building. God makes Himself present to us in a special way and even wants us to receive the Body and Blood of Christ so that we can have God within us. And receiving the Eucharist generally happens during Mass. We may not always feel different from receiving the Eucharist, but we are different. St. John Vianney said, “If we really understood the Mass we would die of joy.” Extreme joy may not be your experience at Mass every week, every month, or even yearly. But just because I don’t experience an emotional response doesn’t mean that the most beautiful union between God and man isn’t taking place.
Just because we feel comfortable in our house doesn’t mean that we are experiencing the consolation of God. The comfort that God came to give was at a much deeper level than just physical comfort. He came to heal our souls. There are many ways in which we can be opposed to God and yet feel physically good. Maybe it’s drinking too much, sleeping when we should go to Mass, or engaging in sexual activity outside of marriage. Those things all feel physically good, and yet do not mean that God is with us our supporting us. Also, the Lord reminded us that following Him may often include suffering of various kinds, which means that we are not made for comfort.
Plus, while we all should have a personal relationship with the Lord, it’s not just me and Jesus. Being baptized means that God joins us to the entire Mystical Body of Christ, the Church, and we are connected to each other. That cannot be fully picked up simply by staying at home, even with other family members, because the Church is not just one family or even just one ethnic group or nationality. To be Catholic means that we embrace all who want to follow Christ.
Lastly, watching the Mass on the computer or on TV never means nor meant that we attended Mass. One can watch the Mass as a lesser way of sanctifying the Lord’s Day, but to truly attend Mass one must be physically present. My earlier words also apply: you cannot receive the Eucharist through livestream, and you cannot fully participate in the larger Mystical Body of Christ on your own through livestream. If one is sick or homebound, then it helps us remember what we would want to attend if were were able. But watching does not equal physical participation.
We celebrate a church building today because it is a kind of sacrament. It is a physical reality, instituted by Christ, which conveys invisible realities and causes graces that flow from the Paschal Mystery. The physical building reminds us that we are part of something bigger than ourselves, each having a role to play to create the temple not made by hands in heaven, where all the elect are joined together, each fulfilling a role. May we not accept the myths that we can worship God on our terms (often guided by our own laziness or preferences), but give ourselves to the worship that our Lord told us would be acceptable worship: worship in spirit and truth. [In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.]